The period after the inspection is where a surprising number of transactions become difficult. A long report arrives, one side reacts to its length, and the conversation loses focus.
Handled well, it is straightforward. Triage the findings, get written estimates for what matters, make a specific and justified request, and keep the discussion attached to facts rather than to the tone of the report.
Triage in three categories
Safety and function
Items that make the home unsafe or that prevent a system from working. These are the legitimate core of any request.
Deferred maintenance
Known wear with a knowable cost. Sometimes negotiable, often simply part of owning a home of that age.
Cosmetic and informational
Observations that do not affect safety or function. Raising these dilutes the credibility of the whole request.
For buyers
- Get written estimates before asking for anything, so the request is grounded in numbers
- Ask for a short prioritized list rather than the full report
- Decide in advance what would actually cause you to walk away
- Consider whether a credit suits you better than repairs done under time pressure
- Remember that the seller is not obligated to agree, and the contract governs what happens next
For sellers
- Read the request against the report rather than reacting to the report's length
- Get your own estimates before responding, especially on larger items
- Consider whether the item would likely recur with the next buyer
- Weigh a credit against arranging repairs yourself, including quality control and timing
- Keep documentation of any work performed, including permits where required
Credits versus repairs
A credit gives the buyer control over how and when work is done, and avoids repairs made hastily to meet a closing date. It may be constrained by lender rules, so confirm what is permissible for the specific loan.
Seller performed repairs give the seller control over cost and contractor selection, and give the buyer a completed item at closing. They also introduce quality and timing risk on both sides.
Neither is universally better. Decide based on the item, the timeline, the loan and how much either party wants control over the outcome.
Repair negotiation checklist
- Findings triaged into three categories
- Written estimates obtained for items being raised
- Request limited to a short prioritized list
- Lender constraints on credits confirmed
- Walk away threshold decided in advance
- Timeline confirmed so any agreed work can be completed before closing
- Documentation and permits retained for work performed
Inspection negotiation is a factual conversation about a small number of items, not a referendum on the house.
Prepare with estimates, ask specifically, and both sides usually find an outcome that keeps the transaction together.
In the middle of a negotiation
Send the findings and the estimates and you will get help shaping a request that is credible and likely to move.
Talk through a negotiation